Which two "Idols" are going home tonight? Who was great last night? Who wasn't? Beehivers Mike and Felicia are here to break all that down. Let them know what you think -- leave a comment about who you think will be eliminated.

Felicia says:
More than an entertaining rock show Tuesday night, "American Idol" showed why LaKisha Jones is really the most gifted of this season's performers. She's not a seasoned professional backup singer (i.e. Melinda Doolittle), isn't a struggling performer on a local scene (i.e. Blake Lewis), or comes from a family familiar with the spotlight (i.e. Jordin Sparks and her previous professional contests). Though LaKisha has some musical background, she is the true raw talent in this field.

She reminded us of her majesty one more time last night ... and I will miss her.

Tonight, AI will kick off two contestants, based on votes from last week's charity show and this week's tallies. On Tuesday, rocker Jon Bon Jovi was the coach, and his group's songs proved more challenging than you'd think. Here's how it stacked up from my vantage point:

The Best: LaKisha! What an awesome way to say goodbye. She actually searched for a song -- "This Ain't A Love Song" -- that would best showcase that beautiful, powerhouse voice. Her tendency to be fierce in facial expression suited this tune. And, once again, I got goose bumps (which I still haven't yet gotten from Melinda, for all her precision and showmanship) when Kiki reached for those moments in a song where you either sail or drown. Simon Cowell, obviously excited that the real Kiki had reappeared after a few weeks of wandering in the desert, even asked to kiss her. Heck, I'd bet a lot of us all wanted to wrap our arms around her.

The Worst: Speaking of either sailing or drowning, what happened to Jordin Sparks? Your mom raises you on Bon Jovi music and you sputter? Trying to look like a rocker with that big, black and red hair style didn't cover up the fact that you were really struggling with the lower ranges. Just wasn't your night, kid.

Biggest Surprise: Blake Lewis, with his beatbox-tinged take on Bon Jovi's classic "Shot Through The Heart." He's the one contestant who takes risks and stays true to his inner voice. I give him big points for innovation. And I'm sure that younger viewers not familiar with Bon Jovi thought that Blake's rendition was oh so cool. But, for someone like me who's of Bon Jovi's generation, it didn't seem right, even though I've liked Blake's earlier styling-ups of other older songs. "Do I like this?" I jotted down last night. "I keep hearing the original in my head -- It's OK, but I'm not lovin' it." Oh, and dying your hair black to look more like a bad-boy rocker is such an obvious ploy. You know better.

So which two go home? My money is on Chris Richardson, for one. He's run out of steam, and Phil Stacey has suddenly hit his stride at the most opportune time. Also, unlike the judges, I thought Chris' singing on "Wanted Dead Or Alive" was more like yelling.

Unfortunately, my second pick is LaKisha. She was hurt by too often picking songs of other AI winners or contestants that forced you to compare her to singers such as Carrie Underwood. Not smart. With more imagination on her part, she could have gone deeper into this competition. I can only hope a producer who understands her takes her on ... Remember, you don't have to win AI to have a successful career. Just ask Jennifer Hudson and Chris Daughtry.

Mike says:
Best: Ummmm, I dunno. Nobody blew my mind. Melinda and LaKisha were both pretty good. As per usual for Melinda. A return to form for LaKisha? Don't know, and we might not ever know.

Worst: Blake Lewis. Oh, where do I begin? The hair? What was that? Fall Out Blake? My Chemical Blakemance? Or him just taking a break from singing to make fart noises with his mouth? Ohhhhh, he was beat-boxing. Ohhh, excuse me. I'm used to good beat-boxers like Rahzel. My apologies. It's just that Blake gives beat-boxing a bad name.

Most surprising: Jordin. Now that she's the one a lot of people (like Felicia) are pulling for, you'd figure young Jordin would have some Spark last night. Nope. Not at all. It was pretty painful, in all honestly. The good news is that I doubt she's going anywhere.

Going home? I'll agree with Felicia that Chris Richardson is done for. It was fun while it lasted, Timberfake. While I think that LaKisha has a very good chance of going, too -- let's recall that she did OK last week and last week's votes still count this week. Now, Blake Lewis sucked last week and was strange enough this week that he might have alienated some people. I'm crossing my fingers that's enough to get him off my TV.