Donald's Oscar blog
Well, folks, it's a new gig for me this year: I'm writing an Oscar blog instead of an Oscar story. It will all be old news by the time the paper hits your doorstep tomorrow morning, right? Instead of spending Oscar night slaving down at the newspaper office -- with a big TV angled at my desk and an extremely rare can (for me) of Diet Pepsi sitting beside me to keep me perked up in the middle of the Short Film (Live Action) winner's acceptance speech -- I'm going to be at home, in my pajamas, curled up on my couch.
This means we get to experience this thing in real time, together. Isn't that special? This is all assuming, of course, that 1) you're able to watch TV and read a computer screen at the same time; 2) haven't been lured in by some other news organization's much fancier Oscar blog site; and 3) could possibly care what I have to say. But come on, this is what the sum total of billions of dollars spent on Internet infrastructure and years of high-tech research have made possible: I can blather LIVE about the Academy Awards. Sort of makes you all misty-eyed for the potential of humankind, eh?
Anyway, I'm here. And I'm blogging. Keep me company: Post a comment or send me an email.
5 p.m. True confession: I've done the Oscar routine since 1996 -- gasp, I'm old -- now, and I've developed some certain rituals. The first one being, namely, that I have totally managed for more than a decade to avoid the Oscar pre-shows. I'd breeze into the newsroom about 15 minutes before the broadcast began, boot up my computer and be ready to write just as the first award was being announced. It was my little way of maintaining my sanity amidst the unrelenting, 24-hour Oscar hype.
But in the spirit of blogging, I've been watching some of the pre-shows. And what dreck they are. The low point so far: Ryan Seacrest on "E" asking Meryl Streep's daughter if her mother is anything like the character she played on "The Devil Wears Prada." Um, yeah, Ryan, you ask a teen on national TV if her mom is a cutthroat, manipulative ice queen and what do you expect her to say? That she doesn't give a very good allowance?
Actually, Seacrest seems like an addled little hen -- an old biddy, for those who keep track of my in-print spelling errors -- clucking around the barnyard. He practically drooled all over Nicole Kidman when asking about her dress; she actually looked physically pained as she clenched her teeth and remained a pro. (What's she going to do, call the cops on him?)
I realize, as I take all this in, that my instinctual reaction to avoid the pre-show was scientifically sound.
5:45 p.m. So how'd Ellen do? I think it's refreshing that she did a low-key, traditionalist-style comic set that didn't rely on gimmicks, elaborate skits or technical wizardry. And the gospel choir she brought on stage was only there for 45 seconds or so -- not long enough to wear thin. As for the Oscar opening, however, with the Errol Morris-style documentary approach -- way flat.
5:53 p.m. First award goes to "Pan's Labyrinth," which makes me really happy. As this year's lengthy Oscar season has crawled along, this amazing film has been getting more and more buzz -- and it looks like it's peaking at just the right time.
5:57 p.m. Love the Will Ferrell, Jack Black and John C. Reilly musical spoof. I have little doubt that some time in the not so near future, Ferrell will indeed take on a project in which he plays a guy with no arms and legs who teaches inner-city gang-bangers "Hamlet." It's the lure of Oscar.
5:59 p.m.: "Pan's Labyrinth," two for two! (So far it's won for makeup and art direction.) Could there be a write-in for best picture?
6:05 p.m.: Best laugh of the evening so far: That clip from "West Bank Story," winner of best short action live film. Get it? West Bank Story? West Side Story? If the Sharks and the Jets can patch up their differences, maybe there's hope for the Israelis and Palestinians.
6:15 p.m. First technical award for "Letters from Iwo Jima," for sound editing. (That sound effects choir was really cool; do you think they hire out for birthday parties?) Regular readers of this blog and my Oscar columns know I have a soft spot for "Iwo Jima" and have my fingers crossed for a big win -- perhaps this is the first Oscar of several?
6:22 p.m. The first biggie: supporting actor. I'm actually kind of nervous. And it goes to .... Alan Arkin, which suggests that 1) the Old Guard is alive and well in the Academy (and hey ho for that), and 2) it was really, really stupid for Eddie Murphy to open in "Norbit" just as the Oscar ballots were being collected. Sweet speech by Alan, by the way. Even though he read it, the catch in his voice made it worthwhile.
6:26 p.m.: What's up with Mark Wahlberg and his dry-as-dust exchange with Ellen? Isn't one of the "marks" of a good actor an ability to improvise (and look comfortable on live TV?) Here's hoping we don't have to listen to his acceptance speech.
6:35 p.m.: So I get these actual hybrid CHILLS up my spine as a proud Prius owner as I watch the stats on global warming flash behind Melissa Etheridge sing "An Inconvenient Truth." Take that, SUV owners! May your carbon emissions smother you while you sleep!
6:40 p.m. Now THAT is great comic timing. Al Gore and Leonardo DiCaprio's fun little skit -- in which Leo keeps asking Gore if he has any big "announcements" to make, and Gore finally acting like he's going to run again for president, only to be drowned out by the orchestra -- is just the right mix of schmaltz and sharp topical humor. As long as Gore doesn't ACTUALLY announce for president, his star will only continue to rise.
6:50 p.m.: Hmmm. "The Departed" picks up adapted screenplay. This isn't actually much of a surprise, but it does signal the wide-open feel of the evening. My pick for this category (sour grapes moment here) is still "Notes on a Scandal," which I think is one of the best adaptations of a novel I've seen in a long time. Oh, and as far as winner William Monahan's speech goes: Love that valium honesty.
7:04 p.m.: "Marie Antoinette" picks up the costume design award -- again, not much of a predictor for what's to come, but possibly a bad sign for "The Queen." Then again, how can you lose when you're recreating Versailles?
7:11 p.m.: More good stuff from Ellen: Nice banter with Clint Eastwood, especially when she winds up asking him for a MySpace photo -- and then directing Steven Spielberg as he takes the shot. I'm finding that I'm really liking Ellen this evening -- she's got a relaxed, sweet style that makes you feel like she's a real bridge between those big, important, unattainable celebrities and the regular average viewing audience. Backing up a bit -- I missed who that actress was who co-presented with Ann Hathaway. That blue dress makes her look so skinny that you wonder if she has room for a spinal column.
7:15 p.m.: "Pan's Labyrinth," for cinematography! Woo-hoo! For a film that got left out of the best-picture category, it's sure making its presence known at these awards.
7:22 p.m.: So the dismally mediocre "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest" wins for visual effects. I begrudgingly admit that this film had its fair share of visual oomph, but I would have liked to have seen it lose just on principle alone. At least it didn't win the makeup award for Johnny Depp's eyeliner.
7:31 p.m.: HUGE HUGE HUGE UPSET: What happened to "Pan's Labyrinth" for foreign film? I figured it had a lock on this category, especially with the technical awards it won so far, but the award goes to Germany's "The Lives of Others." Big surprise.
7:35 p.m.: Supporting actress to Jennifer Hudson; no surprise there. A sweet speech, however, especially at the end, when she gave a last thank-you to Jennifer Holliday, whose legendary performance of the role on Broadway set a standard that no one could ever top, even in the biggest Hollywood movie possible. When you win for Effie in "Dreamgirls," it's best to thank God second and Jennifer Holliday first.
7:49 p.m.: Al Gore wins! If it had been up to the Academy, of course, he would have won the presidency, but I guess he'll have to settle for that Oscar. What with the former vice president's moment in the spotlight as a presenter and as an award winner, this year's awards pretty much turned into a Gore love fest. And good for him. He figured out a way to get a complex, technical message across to the public in a way that penetrated the thick haze that obscures almost any important policy issue today. You might not agree with him, but you have to admit he's galvanized the public.
7:51 p.m.: So you want to know my favorite moment of this Academy Awards? I can tell you even though it isn't over yet. It's the special Oscar for Ennio Morricone, who has written some of the most beautiful movie music ever. His scores for "The Mission," "Cinema Paradiso" and "The Legend of 1900" have had a profound and powerful impact on me since my early days of childhood -- I've listened to his scores faithfully and even reverently, in awe that a composer could eke so much feeling and life out of a melodic line. His speech (in Italian!) mesmerized even if you couldn't understand the language. Here's my commercial plug: If you've never heard of Morricone, do yourself a favor and listen to "The Mission." It's simply beautiful.
8:08 p.m.: Poor Clint. He's getting bashed on this blog (and other places, I'm sure) for some fumbled lines. Come on, give him some slack. He's, like, 200 years old.
8:14 p.m.: "Little Miss Sunshine" gets the prize for original screenplay, which means that it's a very good possibility that this little comedy could walk away with the big prize. Or is this the consolation?
8:20 p.m.: Jennifer Lopez, wearing a rather odd looking dress that looks like something that Cleopatra might have taken a pass on at the Cairo JC Penney, introduces the "Dreamgirls" singers. Here's my question: Will Beyonce get the last sing at the end of the medley? Or will Jennifer Hudson get the honors, considering she's an Oscar winner?
8:29 p.m.: I'm happy to see that Akina Noni Rose, the third Dreamgirl, got a chance at the spotlight, although it would have been nice if Fresno's Sharon Leal (who played the fourth Dreamgirl) had been able to join them. Nice medley, but when you don't end it with "I'm Telling You," it's hard to give it a real "Dreamgirls" finish.
8:30 p.m.: Melissa Etheridge wins for song and thanks ... Al Gore. It's the Al Gore Show!
8:42 p.m. Um, guys, I'm actually getting a little sleepy here. Is it just me, or are we on Hour Five already? When Chris Rock did the show, weren't the maintenance people already cleaning up the Kodak by now?
8:43 p.m.: "The Departed" picks up the award for film editing. A trend toward that film? Or am I just in delirious denial that "Little Miss Sunshine" is going to go down as this century's "Shakespeare in Love"?
8:47 p.m.: Every year, I stop whatever I'm doing and devote my full attention when the "dead people list" runs. It's always a little bittersweet for me -- does time pass that quickly? -- and I'm always genuinely surprised by one or two of the people who passed on during the past year. This time, I'm saddened to learn that Maureen Stapleton, Jack Warden and Jane Wyatt are on the list.
8:53 p.m.: And for best actress, it's: Helen Mirren. But of course. If there was any given tonight, this is it. Mirren gave a majestic speech. I wonder if the real queen was watching?
9:04 p.m.: Forest Whitaker, best actor. I have to admit I really feel for Peter O'Toole right about now. A nice speech from Whitaker.
9:08 p.m.: Best director .... to Martin Scorsese. The Peter O'Toole curse didn't carry through. What makes me happy about this award is that "The Departed" is a really fine film -- and while this award is really for a body of work, as everybody knows, it's great that the film is so good. Great eyebrows, too, Martin. And you can speak so quickly! There were probably more words in his acceptance speech than anyone else the whole evening.
9:13 p.m. Diane Keaton is reading off the nominees, and I really still don't have any idea who's going to win. Pretty exciting.
9:14 p.m.: It's "The Departed." I guess, thinking back to the original screenplay award, that moment was a consolation prize for "LIttle Miss Sunshine." I've always been a strong proponent for the idea that the best director and best film should go together, so it makes me happy to see some consistency.
9:30 p.m.: Before I get to my recap, I have to acknowledge how odd it is to be finishing up on Oscar night just minutes after the show ends. If I were writing a story for the print edition, I'd be in a full adrenaline rush right now, scrambling to make a 10 p.m. deadline. Instead, I'm just about done! (Of course, my colleagues down at The Bee are still scrambling.)
Final thoughts: It was Martin Scorsese's night, no question about it. I'm glad to see him go home with an Oscar. And of course the acting winners are flying high. Eddie Murphy has to be hurting the most out of the losers, just because he was considered a front-runner. (And I'm still feeling for Peter O'Toole; will he ever get another chance at a nomination?) Al Gore has to be loving life right about now; who needs the presidency when you can bask in the adoration of Leonardo DiCaprio? I'm most surprised by "Pan's Labyrinth" getting passed over for best foreign film; after the hype it's received and the technical awards it won, it was almost a slap. In terms of the show itself, it really seemed a dawdling affair, especially compared to some of the speedier shows of the past. I liked Ellen Degeneres -- a lot, and I'd be happy to see her back.
OK, I'm outta here. This blog thing has been fun, and thanks for all the comments. You know what? I'm not going to think about the Oscars for at least 10 months.


Comments:
Yeah, the nominees film at the show's opening was nice for the families of the nominees, but seriously - who were those people?
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 5:52 PM
glad I got a chance to see pans labrynth.........ellen d's opening was pretty good.....
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 6:01 PM
I liked the opening film on all the nominees. It was fun to see the ordinary people mixed in with the big name stars.
Posted by: linda at February 25, 2007 6:08 PM
Didn't some prescient Bee critic or writer say the Danish Poet thing had some buzz behind it? Well you go, you prescient Bee person, whoever you are! (Will?)
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 6:09 PM
Oh, but I love the pre-shows! That's when you get to see all the pretty dresses!
Posted by: Bethany at February 25, 2007 6:16 PM
Sound editing for "Letters from Iwo Jima"? Does that constitute a trend? A foretelling of Best Picturedom to come, Donald?
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 6:17 PM
Donald responds: Yes, but you have to listen to the red-carpet hosts ask such stupid questions! Maybe the best approach is to listen to the pre-show with the sound down.
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 6:21 PM
Alan Arkin! And somewhere, Will Albritton is telling anyone within earshot that he told them so...
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 6:23 PM
best supporting actor...tough category....they were all good......Alan Arkin a very deserving winner....good movie good.....
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 6:25 PM
Donald, you must, must, must tune into Joan Rivers at a red carpet show for something other than the Oscars. She did the CMAs one time and not only appeared to have been drinking, as usual, but had no idea who anyone was. She asked Shania Twain, literally, "How long have you been successful?" No. Idea. Who. She. Was.
Posted by: kent at February 25, 2007 6:26 PM
Donald responds: Yes, but you have to listen to the red-carpet hosts ask such stupid questions! Maybe the best approach is to listen to the pre-show with the sound down.
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 6:26 PM
do you really think Norbit hurt Eddie Murphy that much?....even though it was the #1 movie in the country for a while....
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 6:27 PM
what was up with the Ellen D, Marky mark exchange......FLAT!!
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 6:29 PM
That's hilarious. I actually muted the TV during the pre-show so I could enjoy the pretty dresses in silence.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 6:30 PM
Donald responds: I guess I'm being a little sarcastic when it comes to Eddie Murphy and "Norbit." But every vote counts, and it couldn't have helped to have him playing in one of the worst reviewed films of the year.
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 6:33 PM
Hi - Kent, you say? Are you famous?
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 6:35 PM
good to see Al Gore having a little fun....can you imagine Dick Cheney up there doing that?...LOL!!
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 6:40 PM
Did you catch the telestrater on E!? John Madden meets Joan Rivers meets a Cojo wannabe on the red carpet. And they say technology is a good thing.
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 6:40 PM
uh-oh, Gilligan's Island jokes - that can't be a good sign
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 6:43 PM
I agree...ryan seacrest actually asked some of the dumbest questions imaginable...he is losing his ground quickly...if the show is so green, did folks arrive on some other type of jet?
Posted by: Mary at February 25, 2007 6:43 PM
Jack Nicholson is freaking. me. out.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 6:51 PM
The awards distribution is all over the place - it's nice to see that one film hasn't dominated the categories yet.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 6:53 PM
Hard to identify a trend here - seems to be going in all directions. "Departed," "LMS," "Letters." With Helen Mirren sure to win for "The Queen" and "Babel" sure to pick up something at some point, it's a wide-open horse race, ladies and germs!
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 6:55 PM
Donald responds: I agree re Jack Nicholson; he's like this scary weird animal at the zoo, like a panther, maybe, who sort of seems zoned out on some major zoological drugs but also seems like at any moment could leap at you and rip your face off.
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 6:57 PM
Jack's just giving Britney a little love.
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 7:02 PM
I thought the weird, time-sucking interpretive dances went the way of Debbie Allen years ago.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 7:17 PM
That was Emily Blunt, co-star from The Devil Wears Prada.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 7:19 PM
I have to agree...ellen is doing a very good job.....very comfortable approach to a very BIG show....
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 7:25 PM
good double for Jennifer Hudson.....golden globe + Oscar.....good thing she didn't get the part in Norbit....LOL!!
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 7:36 PM
Jennifer! Even though we knew she'd win, it's still great to see a first-timer genuinely starstruck by the moment.
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 7:39 PM
Yay Ellen! I've forgotten Billy Crystal already.
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 7:42 PM
Donald responds: Ah, Emily Blunt. If the camera really does add 10 pounds, I hope you could keep a few of them.
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 7:45 PM
you go, Jerry...
Posted by: Mary at February 25, 2007 7:46 PM
Jerry Seinfeld + Ellen DeGeneres = stylish, classy and funny show
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 7:48 PM
you go, Jerry...
Posted by: Mary at February 25, 2007 7:48 PM
Wow. Next up ... Nobel Peace Prize?
Posted by: Jack at February 25, 2007 7:49 PM
Just like in Devil, Emily wanted to make sure everyone knows Anne is the Fat One.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 7:53 PM
dirty harry...blowing his lines....too vain to wear his glasses....come on, clint, people younger than you admit to needing magnifcation.
Posted by: Mary at February 25, 2007 7:54 PM
I didn't know Clint Eastwood spoke Italian.....???...very cool...
Posted by: joe at February 25, 2007 8:03 PM
Jerry should have brought Kramer with him to spice this bore-fest up...maybe he could've helped Clint translate.
Posted by: Brian at February 25, 2007 8:09 PM
oh yawwwwwnnnn... what? making fun of jack? I'm there
Posted by: Marty at February 25, 2007 8:11 PM
LMS! Yes!
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 8:14 PM
Jennifer Hudson about to have a wardrobe malfunction. STAND BACK!
Posted by: Brian at February 25, 2007 8:24 PM
dont mess with me, i got 15 right with 6 to go ... haha little miss sunshine.
Posted by: will at February 25, 2007 8:27 PM
Anybody know that Don Munro played the lead in Oliver when he was a kid growing up in Santa Cruz? We all thought he was great but far too smart for an acting career.
Hi Don. You know how to turn a phrase. Keep it up.
Posted by: Steve Smith at February 25, 2007 8:36 PM
Thought the Jack Wild tribute might take you back...
Posted by: Steve Smith at February 25, 2007 8:54 PM
How did I miss Jack Palance dying this year?
Posted by: Amanda at February 25, 2007 9:01 PM
Donald responds: Steve, how are you, buddy? (Bear with me, public, while I say hello to an old high-school chum.) Yes, it made me sad to see that Jack Wild -- who played none other than the Artful Dodger in "Oliver" -- died. How sad!
Posted by: Donald at February 25, 2007 9:02 PM
How you doin now, Will buddy? The Martin Scorsese win was worth the night. Even if "The Departed" was hard to watch for me.
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 9:13 PM
Well, it's Martin Scorsese's year, God bless him. I'm not thrilled "THe Departed" won best picture,, but I'll take it.
Posted by: marty at February 25, 2007 9:16 PM
i'm shocked ... SHOCKED. two years in a row, the wrong movie won best picture. i would have understood babel, but if the departed the movie of the year? hmmm. obviously i dont think so. i ended with 17 right.
Posted by: will at February 25, 2007 9:18 PM
Hey Donald are you about asleep now :-). Boy talk about cut to the chase and close down the show--we are done at 917. Good call on Alan Arkin and well put as to why you thought he would win. Al Gore love fest is being euphemistic--even Melissa's wife Tammy was in tears as he accepted the statue.. And what was up with Jack N's bald look and red glasses? Oh and thanks earlier in one of your pieces on the Oscar nominees for a nod to communication scholars getting Babel--must go for Barbara Walters and more Oscar stories.
Posted by: Kathy Adams at February 25, 2007 9:23 PM
Good job, Donald! You kept me entertained and gave me something to do during the saggy, middle part of the show.
Posted by: Heather at February 25, 2007 9:25 PM
seconding heather, i think youve done a fabulous done with this blog entry, donald.
ellen was great. im glad forest read his speech (his golden globe one was awful). i had a feeling about departed when it won editing over babel. its weird that amelie and pans labrynth didnt win foreign film -- both films had six nominations (i think) -- conspiracy much? happy feet was a shocker too -- first time a pixar film lost? interesting that babel only got one win. i picked no time for nuts, but when i saw that it was an ice age spinoff, i was ecstatic it didnt win. ice age sucked.
i guess i should end my comment when im down to analyzing the best animated short category.
Posted by: will at February 25, 2007 9:45 PM
yes yes. excellent live-blog.
Posted by: tracy at February 25, 2007 10:23 PM
Hi,
Perhaps you are interested in the German movie that won an Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film.
"The Lives of Others" portrays life in communist East Germany and focuses on the totalitarian powers of the secret police, whose stated goal was "to know everything."
I have posted several reviews and the trailer with English subtitles on our blog and recommended a few more German movies, which are available in the US:
http://atlanticreview.org/archives/590-Oscar.html
Posted by: Josh in Berlin at February 26, 2007 6:48 AM
Isn't it interesting that with all the talk about diversity at the Oscars this year, the film that won Best Picture was the least diverse in its casting? Jack Nicholson, Matt Damon, Mark Wahlberg, Leo DiCaprio, Alec Baldwin, Martin Sheen....
I'm just saying.
Posted by: Heather at February 26, 2007 8:27 AM
Donald responds: Point taken about the diversity of "The Departed." However, the cast of "Little Miss Sunshine" wasn't the most diverse group on the planet, either. And then again, 100 years ago it would have shocked WASPs to honor a guy named Scorsese.
Posted by: Donald at February 26, 2007 8:49 AM
Good job. Agree with others...oh Clint! His wife was worse. As I enjoyed "Dream Girls" so much, was disappointed that Eddie and one of their songs didn't win.
Yeah Jennifer! Forget "Little Miss Sunshine" actress...too cutesy. Enjoyed Al Gore.
Posted by: Lorre at February 26, 2007 10:02 AM
Post a comment
(read the comment policy before posting)